LOOKY HERE: IMPORTANT. REALLY . The menu changes seasonally. Please look for our most up-to-date menu on Facebook PieHeavenBakeryCafe. WE'D LOVE TO TAKE YOUR ORDER ON THE WEB BUT WE ARE NOT THAT SLICK. CALL US. WE ARE NICE. (904) 524-7274 ONE MORE THING, PLEASE DO NOT USE THE EMAIL OPTION ON THIS WEBSITE. WE WILL NEVER EVER SEE IT. Paste this link into your browser: https://www.facebook.com/601948906495204/menu/?p_ref=pa


  • We add a bit of nutmeg and coconut to a classic egg custard and bake it in our sweet pie crust. Yummy!

  • Chicken Pot Pie

    $34.00 family , $ 7.95 individual

    Made from scratch with anit-biotic free cage free chicken, organic stock and enough organic vegetable to make Mom happy in our double crust savory crust. It's comfort from Heaven indeed!

  • Apple Pie


  • Key West. Jimmy Buffet. Margaritaville. Inspired us to get the key lime pie drunk with tequila and triple sec. It's pretty awesome.

  • The perfect marriage between mousse and fudge. Nothing fluffy on top - just a simply wonderful smooth chocolate pie in our handmade sweet crust. This pie has resulted in marriage proposals!

  • Juicy but not mushy - that's how each pie should be. And ours is that and more. In a lattice crust.

  • (Shown with optional fancy crust top, available on request) Once a year, before Christmas we make this amazing stewed fruit (no meat). When it's gone, it's gone. Apples, raisins, currants, oranges, lemons, figs, cranberries, sherry, brandy and spices go into this old world favorite.

  • Classic silky lemon curd under lovely meringue in our sweet crust

  • Strawberries baked in our sweet pie crust will remind you of your favorite biscuit and homemade strawberry preserves.

  • A Midwest favorite made with ripe tangy rhubarb and sweet strawberries in our sweet lattice crust. *Available seasonally